Using Primary Sources in the Classroom:
Lesson 3: Point of View: Accounts of Former Slaveholders
1. Background Information for Teachers:
Slavery is most often studied from the point-of-view of the slaveholder, since written records are numerous. This lesson studies slavery from the view of slaveholders. James A. Tait was a wealthy slaveholder in Wilcox County, Alabama. He recorded notes about his slaves, including births and family relationships, in a memorandum book. He also recorded his thoughts and advice to his children on the mangement of slaves and his plantation.
We can also learn about slavery from the point-of-view of slaveholders through interviews done in the twentieth century. In 1912 Herman Clarence Nixon sent questionnaires to former slaveholders and their children as he was preparing a study on slavery in Alabama. The questionnaire solicited information on slaves' housing, clothing, food, employment, family life, education, entertainment, religion, morality, treatment by their owners, escapes, punishment, emancipation, and relationships and attitudes toward free Negroes and nonslaveholding whites. Nixon was born in 1886 in Calhoun County, Alabama and he died in 1967. Nixon was an author, educator and sociologist, who is best remembered as a member of the Vanderbilt (or Nashville) Agrarians and for his active role in Southern social politics of the 1930s and 1940s.
For more information on Nixon see:
Sarah Newman Shouse, Hillbilly Realist: Herman Clarence Nixon of Possum Trot. The University of Alabama Press, 1986.
2. Learning Objectives:
Upon completion of this activity, students should be able to:
1. Describe the housing and living conditions of slaves.
3. Suggested lesson:
2. Distribute copies of Document 1 to each student and ask them to read the questions.
3. Divide the class into three groups and assign a different document to each group. Instruct each group to read their document and answer the following questions:
a. Was the correspondent conscientious in answering the questions?
b. Consider the time period when the questions were answered.
c. How old was the correspondent at the beginning of the Civil War?
d. Compare the answers with the descriptions of slavery given in Lesson 2.
e. Compare the answers with the descriptions of slavery in your textbook.
f. Locate DeKalb County, Wilcox County, East Lake, on an Alabama map.
g. Compare the treatment of slaves on large plantations with those on smaller farms.
(In the 1850 U.S. Census a person who owned more than 50 slaves was identified as a planter; persons owning fewer than 50 slaves were identified as farmers.)
h. Discuss possible reasons that former slaves might return to the plantation after they were emancipated.
Document 2: "O.J. McCann letter," H.C. Nixon Responses to Questionnaire on Slavery, LPR91, Alabama Department of Archives and History, Montgomery, Alabama.
Document 3: "J.W. Winston letter," H.C. Nixon Responses to Questionnaire on Slavery, LPR91, Alabama Department of Archives and History, Montgomery, Alabama.
Document 4: "D.W. McIntosh letter," H.C. Nixon Responses to Questionnaire on Slavery, LPR91, Alabama Department of Archives and History, Montgomery, Alabama.
Document 5: "Regulations for the sickly season," James A. Tait Memorandum Book, Tait Family Papers, LPR35, Alabama Department of Archives and History, Montgomery, Alabama.
Document 6: "Negro houses," James A. Tait Memorandum Book, Tait Family Papers, LPR35, Alabama Department of Archives and History, Montgomery, Alabama.